Butterfinger Shake Recipe by Mindi Cherry FacebookPinEmail Need a cool ice creamy treat today! To make these Butterfinger Shakes you need: 3 scoops (baseball size) of Vanilla 2 oz. half & half 2 Tbs. Peanut Butter 2 Tbs. Chocolate syrup ½ Butterfinger Bar Head over to Hott Mama in the City for the recipe! More DessertNo Bake Chocolate Granola BarsHomemade Apple DumplingsPumpkin Spice Cake with Cream Cheese FrostingHomemade Apple Cider Donuts Recipe