Butterfinger Shake Recipe by Mindi Cherry FacebookPinEmail Need a cool ice creamy treat today! To make these Butterfinger Shakes you need: 3 scoops (baseball size) of Vanilla 2 oz. half & half 2 Tbs. Peanut Butter 2 Tbs. Chocolate syrup ½ Butterfinger Bar Head over to Hott Mama in the City for the recipe! More DessertYogurt Popsicles with Fruit - Just 4 Ingredients!No Bake Chocolate Granola BarsHomemade Apple DumplingsPumpkin Spice Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting